Doing our best since 2009

Perhaps you’d like to read our newsletter?

Phantom Limb

by Brian Evenson
Coffee House Press, October 2026

In 2009, Brian Evenson brought out  Last Days, a hybrid of hardboiled detective fiction and body horror. In Phantom Limb, Evenson engages with the same tropes of gore and horror, yet what emerges from Phantom Limb is a character whose interests extend beyond mere survival, a man engaged in an authentic search for identity and nursing the small hope of becoming whole.

Phantom Limb picks up immediately after the brutal killing spree that closed Last Days. Both novels follow an ex-detective named Kline, who is only ever referred to as Kline or Mr. Kline. Without an identity of his own, he is pulled into the Brotherhood of Mutilation, a cult that practices voluntary self-amputation to get closer to God, simply because he already has a missing hand. At the opening of Phantom Limb, Kline is serving a prison sentence under an assumed identity. Though prison grants him temporary respite, the Brotherhood soon finds him again, now fractured into even more volatile offshoot sects. 

I’m a fan of Evenson’s work. I reviewed his collection Good Night, Sleep Tight in these pages in 2024. I love his short stories for their blend of fairy tale, horror, and science fiction. They have an uncanny weirdness that feels otherworldly yet familiar, and I liked how the fear and dread sneak up on you. Both fast-paced noir detective thrillers, Last Days and Phantom Limb come at the reader full-force with a nonstop, gritty, hard-edged reality. 

Though these noirs are different from some of Evenson’s other writing, they are just as addictive. When I picked up Phantom Limb, I was immediately drawn into Kline’s world. Evenson maintains a matter-of-fact style even while describing extremely violent scenes, including amputations, both forced and voluntary, and brutal killings, which somehow makes them more palatable. 

I once had a dream about a dead body in my washing machine. It felt so real, even though I knew it wasn’t, that I avoided opening the lid all day. That feeling returns when I’m reading Evenson. Evenson grounds his extreme, bizarre world in the most ordinary sensory details. When Kline is in prison, a guard brings him his breakfast:

An officer appeared at the end of the corridor, carrying a battered tin tray. There was an open pint of milk on it, a pressed paper bowl full of flaccid cornflakes already soaking in milk, a heap of already browning apple slices. 

The description makes that breakfast feel intensely real, as if I might look to my own table and find those soggy cornflakes right in front of me. Combined with Evenson’s perfectly tuned dialogue and infused with an unexpected humor, these grounded details mix with the exaggerated gore to turn Kline’s fight to remain human into something intimate and convincing.

In the first book, Kline is at home, lonely and depressed, on the verge of starving himself and unable to force himself to leave his bed. With every page, Kline becomes less human. In Phantom Limb, Kline is preoccupied with clawing his way back to being human, discarding his violent past to become someone new. From the beginning, in prison, Kline says his assumed name, Werner, over and over.

Maybe he could stand to be alive if he were someone else. He tried to convince himself that other name, Kline, belonged to someone else, another person entirely—that whatever this Kline had done had nothing to do with him, with Werner. […] Werner was still human, Kline, on the other hand was not. 

Through this exploration of identity, Evenson introduces an element absent from Last Days, a hope for a transformation beyond what this world offers. The idea is that Kline may not find wholeness or humanity in this world but might find it by accessing another realm. It is unclear whether this is attainable or merely something he dreams of. 

Toward the novel’s end, Kline is asked what he wants. He answers: “What does anyone want except to stay alive?” But is it enough? Kline’s yearning for another identity, for something to make him human and whole again, suggests that it may not be. Kline’s experiences in Phantom Limb underscore the reality that no one passes through life unchanged. Struggle and uncertainty remain all too familiar.

+++

Brian Evenson has won the World Fantasy Award, The International Horror Guild Award, and the Shirley Jackson Award. He is also the recipient of three O. Henry Awards, a Guggenheim Fellowship, and was a finalist for the Ray Bradbury Prize. He lives in LA. 

+

Emily Webber is a writer of criticism, fiction, and creative nonfiction. Her work has appeared in Rain Taxi, the Ploughshares Blog, The Rumpus, Writer, America Magazine, and elsewhere. She’s the author of a chapbook of flash fiction, Macerated.

Join our newsletter?