Our Research Notes series invites authors to describe their process for a recent book, with “research” defined as broadly as they would like. This week, Adam Peterson writes about Any Time But This Time, winner of the Grace Paley Prize for Short Fiction from The Ohio State University press.
+
Write the Past Like You Would Write The Present

In certain neighborhoods on the east side of Los Angeles, it’s not uncommon to come across cottages that look like they were stolen from the dreams of some consumptive tots who died before the war. Which war? Pick whichever one you like because it’s all bullshit anyway. These homes were mostly built in the 1920s and 30s around the first Disney studio which is now a supermarket where an avocado costs $6.
The consumptive tots could never.
The Disney thing is no accident, but the inspiration mostly runs the opposite way from what you might think. These cottages were drawn into the films rather than the films drawing them into real life (although it’s fun to imagine the first Disney adult showing up at an architect’s office holding a cartoon still and saying, “Like that but without the witch.”)
After WWI, the movies were booming, scientists had declared that Los Angeles would absolutely 100% never catch on fire, and a bunch of shellshocked American soldiers had seen Europe, didn’t care for how it kept exploding, and wanted to retreat into the stories they knew as kids.
Not-yet-popsicled Walt was about to get on this same kick, and so the houses and the cartoons were both part of the “You know what was nice? Bedtime with Mommy” zeitgeist. None of it has much in common with any real past or place or protagonist who sings on her way to falling in love with a prince. That person didn’t exist. That person sucks. The witches were right.
So to see these buildings now is to grapple with nostalgia for the nostalgia of the nostalgia of the who-even-fucking-knows. Some incestuous 19th century Germans is my best guess, but after that slander I doubt they’ll admit it. This isn’t anyone’s fault. Nostalgia is as hardwired into humanity as our desire to anonymously insult people on walls. Actually, these might be the only two things shared across every culture. Some lady is a pretty good hang and everything was better yesterday.
It’s inevitable. Even you’ll find yourself kicking through the ashes of what was once Silver Lake telling anyone who will listen how much better avocados tasted when they were the criminally low price of $6.
Nostalgia is the fundamental nature of our relationship with the past, and anyone choosing to write a story set in the past has to grapple with it.
The worst and most common outcome is to feed our nostalgia (or, really, let that nostalgia feed on us) and end up with some schlock about how good things used to be, even though they absolutely weren’t. Because, just like with our twitchy doughboys building castles in Eagle Rock, what we really miss more than the alleged innocence is the comfort of knowing we survived it all. I can trust I made it through the 90s, but a plane might crush my house before…I finish…this sentence…no? Fine. Maybe tomorrow.
Of course this doesn’t just impact how we talk about our own past but all of history. We’re not afraid of it, and so we can’t really understand it, not like it was lived. Without fear, whatever nuances or contradictions become incomprehensible, whatever tragedies and injustices invisible. Call it the Gone with the Wind effect, if you like, and then please never do it.
However, many of us are too smart—or at least too infected by what might broadly be called post-modernism—for this trap and pursue the second worst outcome: treating the past as grimmer and more foreign than it was.
Oddly, this often ends up horseshoe-theorying the author around to being just as nostalgic but for the bad things. Somehow all the terrible shit is more “authentic.” Sure, a man’s family might die of cholera, but doesn’t that just prove how meaningful his quiet rage is? No. Shut up. Some kids are dead. That rugged paragon of masculinity would have more in common with a dude posting on Reddit about the Cleveland Browns quarterback situation than he does with the caricatures in some gritty reboot of humanity.
But if both of these impulses are nostalgic and therefore small-c conservative (and, let’s face it, usually big C too), how should we tell stories in and about the past that allow us to move forward? That feel as alive as we feel? Because there’s one thing we can count on: there’s going to be a fuckload more past. For writers, it’s basically our greatest resource. That and the future.
The future. That’s a good place to start. When we write about what’s to come, we imagine. We dream. We invent. But when we write about what’s happened, we research. We explain. We imitate. If you had to learn what people ate in 900AD, you’re sure as hell going to squeeze it in there, right, sire?
But would it be so bad if you just made it up? The same way you might look at your burrito bowl and project forward to create the space slop an interstellar assassin would eat? It depends, of course, but even by thinking of the past as a place equally open to imagination—and eligible for inserting your own experience—you’re freeing yourself from the burden of translating an illegible text. You can’t get it right anyway, and nostalgia (one way or the other) is what seeps in to fill the cracks with false truth.
What’s actually true is that you’re writing from and for the present. And thank god, that’s so much easier. The present is the place you are, a place you understand, a place—most importantly—you fear. That’s the essential part. Because I assure you no matter what time period you’re writing about, we haven’t actually changed enough beyond that fact to matter.
There aren’t past people or future people. There are people. And we’re terrified.
Do you think the guy who got wine drunk and ordered a pyramid thought he lived in “history?” He was scared to die and be forgotten. So are you. So am I. So we fall in love and have families and write books and pray for eternal life. We mix our regrets over yesterday with our hopes for tomorrow, and we try to make it through another today. And today we surround ourselves with things that will make us happy for as long as we can manage, and, yes, sometimes that’s a dumb fucking cottage commemorating how we didn’t get bayonetted in the Argonne.
O, sorry, you thought I hated the cottages, I don’t hate the cottages. Nostalgia is natural, and I’ll take something ridiculous but human over something boring and self-serious every time. They might not be what I’d build, but then why would they be? We all have to create our own monuments, and they have no choice but to be a compromise between what’s gone and what’s ahead. You’ve done your duty to yesterday by caring about its stories at all. Now try to steal that same attention from tomorrow.
Because the goal here isn’t to get an A on some history final. The goal is to add your voice to the story people have been telling since there were people. And that’s not a story about history, that’s a story about how we stumbling into meaning while trying to outrun it.
So take what you know to be true and make the rest up. Everyone else was.
+++
Originally from Nebraska, Adam Peterson now lives in Los Angeles, California. He’s the author of the prose poetry collections My Untimely Death, The Flasher, and [SPOILER ALERT] (with Laura Eve Engel). His films have played (and won awards) at HollyShorts, Fantasia Fest, and Just for Laughs among other festivals. Eagle Scout.